Responding to COVID-19: insight, support and guidance

Affordable housing is a health issue

01-07-2020

By Sheldon Wood, Lead CIPFA Benefits Advisor

The housing crisis in the UK has been years in the making. As a result, many of the most vulnerable people in our society do not have access to safe and affordable housing during normal times, let alone during the unprecedented COVID-19 crisis.

Housing is a health issue, and we cannot guarantee the wellbeing of vulnerable members of our communities unless we can guarantee a reliable roof over their heads. COVID-19 has increased the uncertainty surrounding housing affordability and availability throughout the UK. Special attention must be paid to how we can support those who are struggling to find affordable housing amid the pandemic. 

CIPFA recently unveiled a suite of new housing analytics tools, Housing 360, which painted a bleak picture of the housing crisis. Our analysis has shown that it would take 17 years on average for local authorities to provide council housing to all who are currently waiting for it. In the North West of England, the numbers are even higher with those waiting for council housing expecting to wait, on average, up to 39 years.

Additional problems in the private rented sector in recent years have been due to demand on supply, exacerbated by reduced affordability as a result of reductions in the value of the Local Housing Allowance (LHA) which, prior to 2010 was fixed at the 30th percentile of local rental markets.

Since 2010, there have been a series of cuts to LHA rates by removing the link with the 30th percentile and, instead, uprating rates alongside general benefits uprating, including the four-year benefits freeze since 2016.

This has resulted in the removal of the link between LHA rates and local markets and in LHA rates failing to remain in line with rent inflation. As a result, by the end of 2019, on average across England, fewer than 10% of properties were available at rent levels below the LHA rate, and, in some areas, fewer than 5%.

This led to benefits claimants struggling to pay rent and still have enough left over to feed their family and pay bills. In some cases, this caused homelessness to spike and increased use of temporary accommodation, as councils struggle to manage demand due to a lack of affordable housing options.

A September 2019 report from Crisis highlighted that investing in LHA rates so they cover the 30th percentile, or the cheapest third of rents, would prevent more than 6,000 households from becoming homeless over three years, and lift 32,000 households out of poverty, including 35,000 children.

The report estimates that £5.5bn of avoided cost could come from reducing the need for temporary accommodation and homelessness services, as well as reducing the need for services relating to homelessness such as health. Once the cost to the government (£3.3bn) of the investment over three years is taken into account, this still leaves benefits of £2.1bn.

An LGA report, published in February 2020 also concluded that, in many parts of the country, there were few properties available at or below the LHA rate. The report showed that restoring LHA rates to their pre-2016 levels would result in:

  • an average council needing to house 300 fewer people in temporary accommodation, or 101,000 nationally;
  • the average cost of using temporary accommodation for a council would reduce by between £1.4m and £3m;
  • the average council would see 650 more households able to cover the cost of their rent with their LHA payments, or 220,000 nationally. This would help reduce financial hardship on them when trying to meet their housing costs.

In response to the coronavirus outbreak, the government announced in the 2020 Budget that LHA rates would be returned to the 30th percentile for the financial year 2020/21. This will have an immediate impact on current levels of homelessness in Great Britain and will help thousands of people keep their homes. This is a welcome and long overdue measure that will result in more private rented accommodation becoming affordable for universal credit and housing benefit claimants and increases in income for many already residing in the private rented sector.

However, the household benefit cap levels have not been increased. So, in some cases, this increase in benefit income will be capped, reducing affordability, especially for lone parents and families. Local authorities may need to consider whether to make discretionary housing payments (DHP) in such situations to offset this. In order to avoid these issues, household benefit cap levels should be reviewed or abolished.

The true cost of homelessness in terms of health, wellbeing, social mobility would be far greater than any of the costs identified in remedying the problem. Housing is not purely a financial transaction. Society as well as the individual benefit from good housing provision.

This article first appeared in Inside Housing.

Further reading

CIPFA offers a wealth of insight, resources and solutions on our Tackling the Housing Crisis page. There you will find context and links to resources and other solutions such as our new CIPFA Housing 360 service.

For ongoing help and support around the latest housing developments and the latest responses and case studies from local authority housing professionals please visit our Housing Advisory Network.